Military culture: Understanding deeper dynamics through the warrior archetype
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53477/2284-9378-24-01Keywords:
Archetype, Canadian Armed Forces, Carl Jung, military culture, organizational behavior, psychology, the unconscious.Abstract
This paper proposes a new psycho-sociological approach to understanding military culture change, built on the notion of warrior archetype, in line with psychiatrist Carl Jung’s concept of archetype. It contends that military culture and its related institutional forms fundamentally seek to mobilize on an ongoing basis human energy produced through the activation of the warrior archetype. The archetype is built on enhancing feelings of strength in numbers, and empowerment through socially sanctioned actions and potential use of violence. It uses the example of the Canadian Armed Forces culture change effort to illustrate that any such planned organizational culture change will fail if it does not remain consistent with activating the warrior archetype, as its central dynamic and purpose.
References
Aquino, Karl, Americus Reed, Stefan Thau and Dan Freeman. 2007. “A Grotesque and Dark Beauty: How Moral Identity and Mechanisms of Moral Disengagement Influence Cognitive and Emotional Reactions to War.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 43 (3): 385-392.
Ashikali, Tanachia and Sandra Groeneveld. 2015. “Diversity management for all? An empirical analysis of diversity management outcomes across groups.” Personnel Review 44 (5): 757-780.
Aurelio, Jeanne L. 1995. “Using Jungian Archetypes to Explore Deeper Levels of Organizational Culture: Facing our organization’s psyche.” Journal of Management Inquiry 4 (4): 347-368.
Balogun, Julia and Mark Jenkins. 2003. “Re-conceiving change management: A knowledgebased perspective.” European Management Journal 21 (2): 247-257.
BBC News. 2016. “Australian of the Year is equality activist Gen David Morrison.” British Broadcasting Corporation. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-australia-35378881.
Becker, David V. and Steven L. Neuberg. 2019a. “Archetypes Reconsidered as Emergent Outcomes of Cognitive Complexity and Evolved Motivational Systems.” Psychological Inquiry 30 (2): 59–75.
__. 2019b. “Pushing Archetypal Representational Systems Further.” Psychological Inquiry 30 (2): 103-109
Becker, Ernest. 1962. The Birth and Death of Meaning. New York: Free Press.
Berger, Peter L. and Thomas Luckmann. 1966. The Social Construction of Reality: A treatise in the sociology of knowledge. New York: Anchor.
Bloeser, Katharine and Heliana Ramirez. 2019. “Queering the Warrior Archetype: LGBTQ Servicewomen.” In Invisible Veterans: What Happens when Military Women Become Civilians again, edited by Kate Hendricks Thomas and Kyleanne Hunter, 113-131. Santa Barbara: Praeger.
Bourne, Humphrey and Mark Jenkins. 2013. “Organizational values: A dynamic perspective.” Organization studies 34 (4): 495-514.
Bowles, Martin L. 1993. “The Gods and Goddesses: Personifying Social Life in the Age of Organization.” Organization Studies 14 (3): 395–418.
Brown, Mary Louise, Seonaidh McDonald and Fiona Smith. 2013. “Jungian Archetypes and Dreams of Social Enterprise.” Journal of Organizational Change Management 26 (4): 670-688.
Burnes, Bernard. 2015. “Understanding Resistance to Change – Building on Coch and French.” Journal of Change Management 15 (2): 92-116.
Bernard Burnes and Philip Jackson. 2011. “Success and Failure in Organizational Change: An Exploration of the Role of Values.” Journal of Change Management 11 (2): 133-162.
Campbell, Joseph. 1991. The Power of Myth. New York: Anchor Books.
Carlsen, Arne. 2016. “On the tacit side of organizational identity: Narrative unconscious and figured practice.” Culture and Organization 22(2): 107-135.
Carpenter, Ted Galen ed. 1997. Delusions of Grandeur: The United Nations and Global Intervention. Washington: Cato Institute.
Charron, Andrea and Jim Ferguson. 2019. “Canada and Defence Against Help: The Wrong Theory for the Wrong Country at the Wrong Time.” In Canadian Defence Policy in Theory and Practice, edited by Thomas Juneau, Philippe Lagassé, and Srdjan Vucetic, 99–115. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Castano, Emanuele, Benhard Leidner and Patrycja Slawuta. 2008. “Social identification processes, group dynamics and the behaviour of combatants.” International Review of the Red Cross 90 (870): 259-271.
Chen, Rongxin Roger and Narasimhan, Rangapriya Priya Kannan. 2015. “Formal Integration Archetypes in Ambidextrous Organizations.” R&D Management 45 (3): 267–286.
Chuang, You‐Ta, Robin Church and Jelena Zikic. 2004. “Organizational culture, group diversity and intra‐group conflict.” Team Performance Management: An International Journal 10 (no. 1/2): 26-34.
Cloud, Doug. 2019. “The Rise of the Gay Warrior: Rhetorical Archetypes and the Transformation of Identity Categories.” Discourse & Communication 13 (1): 26–47.
Coletta, Amanda. 2023. “Trudeau told NATO that Canada will never meet spending goal, Discord leak shows.” Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/nationalsecurity/2023/04/19/canada-military-trudeau-leaked-documents/.
Coman, Alin, Charles B. Stone, Emanuele Castano and William Hirst. 2014. “Justifying Atrocities: The Effect of Moral-Disengagement Strategies on Socially Shared RetrievalInduced Forgetting.” Psychological Science 25 (6): 1281–1285.
Coyne, Christopher J. 2011. “Delusions of Grandeur: On the Creeping Militarization of U.S. Foreign Policy.” GMU Working Paper in Economics, no. 11-03. https://ssrn.com/abstract=1753318.
Dalpiaz, Elena and Giada Di Stefano. 2018. “A universe of stories: Mobilizing narrative practices during transformative change.” Journal of Strategic Management 39 (3): 664-696.
Demers, Anne. 2011. “When Veterans Return: The Role of Community in Reintegration.” Journal of Loss and Trauma 16 (2): 160-179.
Diamond, Michael A. 2007. “Organizational Change and the Analytic Third: Locating and Attending to Unconscious Organizational Psychodynamics.” Psychoanalysis, Culture & Society 12 (2): 142-164.
Duncanson, Claire. 2015. “Hegemonic Masculinity and the Possibility of Change in Gender Relations.” Men and Masculinities 18 (2): 231-248.
Durand, Gilbert. 1996. Introduction à la mythodologie. Paris: Albin Michel.
Duval-Lantoine, Charlotte. 2023. “Culture Change Beyond Misconduct: Addressing Systemic Barriers.” Canadian Global Affairs Institute. Policy Perspective paper. https://www.cgai.ca/culture_change_beyond_misconduct_addressing_systemic_barriers.
Enns, Carolyn Zerbe. 1994. “Archtypes and gender: Goddesses, warriors, and psychological health.” Journal of Counseling and Development 73 (2): 127-133.
Erwin, Dennis G. and Andrew N. Garman. 2010. “Resistance to organizational change: Linking research and practice.” Leadership & Organization Development Journal31(1): 39–56.
Festinger, Leon. 1954. “A theory of social comparison processes.” Human Relationships 1: 117-140.
Fletcher, Joseph F. and Jennifer Hove. 2012. “Emotional Determinants of Support for the Canadian Mission in Afghanistan: A View from the Bridge.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 45 (1): 33–62.
Galloway, Gloria. 2007. “Hillier decries military ‘decade of darkness’.” Globe and Mail. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/hillier-decries-militarys-decadeof-darkness/article20393158/.Geisler, David. 2001. “Bottom-feeders: People who reject change.” Executive Excellence 18 (12): 19.
Gover, Laura, Michael Halinski and Linda Duxbury. 2016. “Is it Just Me? Exploring Perceptions of Organizational Culture Change.” British Journal of Management 27: 567–582.
Government of Canada. 2023a. Canadian Military Journal 23. Vol. 23, no. 3. http://www.journal.forces.gc.ca/cmj-23.3-toc-en.html
__. 2023b. Conduct and culture change progress tracker. Ottawa: Department of National Defence. https://www.canada.ca/en/department-national-defence/services/conductand-culture/conduct-and-culture-tracker.html-2022-2023.
Gray, Richard. 1996. Archetypal Explorations: An integrative approach to human behavior. London: Routledge.
Grey, Chris. 2017. A Very Short, Fairly Interesting and Reasonably Cheap Book about Studying Organizations, London: Sage Publications Ltd.
He, Hongwei and Yehuda Baruch. 2009. “Transforming organizational identity under institutional change.” Journal of Organizational Change Management 22 (6): 575-599.
Helkama, Klaus. 2012. “Equality, Trust, Fairness, and Cohesion.” In The Science of Unit Cohesion – Its Characteristics and Impacts, edited by Mikael Salo, and Risto Sinkko. Finish National Defence University, Department of Behavioural Sciences, Series 1 (Number 1): 109-113.
Hennelly, R. Kevin. 1988. “The Psychological Roots of Political and Ideological Violence: A Jungian Perspective.” Alternatives 13: 219-252.
Hopper, Tristin. 2024. “The Canadian military’s all-in embrace of far-left ‘anti-oppression’ dogma.” National Post. https://nationalpost.com/opinion/first-reading-the-canadian-militarys-all-in-embrace-of-far-left-anti-oppression-dogma.
Hubbart, Jason A. 2022. “Organizational change: considering truth and buy-in.” Administrative Sciences 13 (1). https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3387/13/1/3.
Hughes, Mark. 2022. “Reflections: How Studying Organizational Change Lost Its Way.”Journal of Change Management 22 (1): 8-25.
Hunt, Harry T. 2012. “A collective unconscious reconsidered: Jung’s archetypal imagination in the light of contemporary psychology and social science.” Journal of Analytical Psychology 57: 76-98.
Inabinett, Jean M. and Julie M. Ballaro. 2014. “Developing an Organization by Predicting Employee Retention by Matching Corporate Culture with Employee’s Values: A Correlation Study.” Organization Development Journal 32 (1): 55-74.
Jeffery, Michael. 2010. “Inside Canadian Forces Transformation.” Canadian Military Journal10 (2): 9-18.
Jonsen, Karsten, Charles Galunic, John Weeks and Tania Braga. 2015. “Evaluating espoused values: Does articulating values pay off?.” European Management Journal33 (5): 332-340.
Jones, Jenni, Janet Firth, Claire Hannibal and Michael Ogunseyin. 2019. “Factors contributing to organizational change success or failure: a qualitative meta-analysis of 200 reflective case studies.” In Evidence-based initiatives for organizational change and development, edited by Robert G. Hamlin, Andrea D. Ellinger, and Jenni Jones, 155-178. Hershey: IGI Global.
Juneau, Thomas, Philippe Lagassé and Srdjan Vucetic eds. 2020. Canadian defence policy in theory and practice. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan
Jung, Carl. 1959. The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
__. 1969. “On the nature of the psyche.” Jung Collected Work, volume 8, 159-234. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1969.
Karasvirta, Saara and Satu Teerikangas. 2022. “Change organizations in planned change–A closer look.” Journal of Change Management 22 (2): 163-201.
Kociatkiewicz, Jerzy and Monika Kostera. 2010. “Experiencing the Shadow: Organizational Exclusion and Denial within Experience Economy.” Organization 17 (2): 257–282.
Leuprecht, Christian and Joel J. Sokolsky. 2015. “Defense Policy ‘Walmart Style’: Canadian Lessons in ‘not-so-grand’ Grand Strategy.” Armed Forces & Society 41(3): 541-562.
Lewin, Nicholas. 2009. Jung on War, Politics and Nazi Germany: Exploring the theory of archetypes and the collective unconscious. London: Karnac.
Long, Susan. 2019. “The unconscious won’t go away-especially in organisations.” Organisational and Social Dynamics 19 (2): 218-229, 289-290.
Maaranen, Anna and Tienari Janne. 2020. “Social media and hyper-masculine work cultures.” Gender, Work & Organization 27: 1127‐1144.
Maloney, Marcus and Scott Doidge. 2021. “Homegrown Heroes and New War Warriors: Post-9/11 Depictions of Warfare in Call of Duty.” In Militarization and the Global Rise of Paramilitary Culture: Post-heroic reimagining of the warrior, edited by West, Brad and Thomas Crosbie, 57-74. Singapore: Springer.
Marion, James and John Lewis. 2020. How to Fail at Change Management: A Manager’s Guide to the Pitfalls of Managing Change. Lowell: Business Expert Press.
Massie, Justin and Srdjan Vucetic. 2019. “Canadian Strategic Cultures: From Confederation to Trump.” In Canadian Defence Policy in Theory and Practice, edited by Thomas Juneau, Philippe Lagassé, and Srdjan Vucetic, 29-44. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Maurer, Rick. 1996. Beyond the wall of resistance: Unconventional strategies that build support for change. Austin: Bard Books.
McDougall, William. 1908. An introduction to social psychology. London: Methuen.
Milgram, Stanley. 1974. Obedience to authority. New York: Harper and Row.
Mills, Jon. 2013. “Jung’s metaphysics.” International Journal of Jungian Studies 5 (1): 19-43.
Mitroff, Ian I. 1983. “Archetypal Social System Analysis: On the deeper structure of human systems.” Academy of Management Review 8 (3): 387-397.
Monneyron, Frédéric. 2014. “Gilbert Durand et l’étude des mythes.” Sociétés, no. 123: 41-49.
Moore, Robert and Douglas Gillette. 1990. King, Warrior, Magician, Lover: Rediscovering the archetypes of the mature masculine. New York: HarperCollins.
Moxnes, Paul. 2013. “The Hero’s dream and other primordial patterns of imagery: Archetypal influences on organisational fantasies and ideations.” Journal of Organizational Change Management 26 (4): 638-653.
Mumby, Dennis K. 2005. “Theorizing resistance in organization studies: A dialectical approach.” Management Communication Quarterly 19 (1): 19-44.
Murstein, Bernard I. 1957. “Studies in projection: a critique.” Journal of projective techniques21 (2): 129-136.
O’Brien, John. 2020. “Corporate Complex: Diagnostic and Application”. In The Professional Practice of Jungian Coaching: Corporate Analytical Psychology, edited by Nora O’Brien, and John O’Brien, 127-133. London: Routledge.
O’Donovan, Gabrielle. 2018. Making Organizational Change Stick: How to Create a Culture of Partnership Between Project and Change Management. New York: Routledge.
Oreg, Shaul. 2006. “Personality, context, and resistance to organizational change.” European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology 15 (1): 73–101.
Pardo-del-Val, Manuela and Clara Martínez-Fuentes. 2003. “Resistance to change: A literature review and empirical study.” Management Decision 41 (4): 148–155.
Park, Ernest S. and Verlin B. Hinsz. 2006. “Strength and safety in numbers: A theoretical perspective on group influences on approach and avoidance motivation.” Motivation and Emotion 30 (2): 135-142.
Pearson, Carol. 1986. The Hero Within: Six archetypes to live by. San Francisco: Harper and Row.
Pendlebury, Jarrod. 2020. “‘This Is a Man’s Job:’ Challenging the Masculine ‘Warrior Culture’ at the U.S. Air Force Academy. Armed Forces & Society 46 (1): 163-184.
Pisch, Anita. 2016. Stalin in Soviet Posters, 1929–1953: Archetypes, Inventions & Fabrications. Canberra: Australian National University Press.
Porter, Bernard. 2023. Britain, Europe and the world 1850-1986: Delusions of grandeur. London: Taylor and Francis.
Prasad, Pushkala and Anshuman Prasad. 2000. “Stretching the iron cage: The constitution and implications of routine workplace resistance.” Organization Science 11: 387- 403.
Prince, Melvin and James Forr. 2021. “Metaphor elicitation: A new way to assess organizational culture.” The Psychologist-Manager Journal 24 (4): 199-219.
Rafferty, Alannah Eileen, Nerina L. Jimmieson and Achilles A. Armenakis. 2013. “Change readiness: A multilevel review.” Journal of Management 39 (1): 110–135.
Resteigne, Delphine and Philippe Manigart. 2021. “The Different Soldiers: A Look at Diversity and Inclusion in Military Organizations”. In Yin-Yang Military:
Ambidextrous Perspectives on Change in Military Organizations, edited by Jacqueline Heeren-Bogers, René Moelker, Esmeralda Kleinreesink, Jan Van der Meulen, Joseph Soeters, and Robert Beeres, 125-139. Springer: Cham.
Roesler, Christian. 2012. “Are archetypes transmitted more by culture than biology? Questions arising from conceptualizations of the archetype.” Journal of Analytical Psychology 57: 223–246
Statista.com. 2024. “Canada: Ratio of military spending to gross domestic product (GDP) from 2012 to 2022”. https://www.statista.com/statistics/810367/ratio-of-military-expenditure-to-gross-domestic-product-gdp-canada/.
Samuels, Robert. 2020. “Simon Clarke and the Politics and Psychoanalysis of Racism.” Psychoanalysis, Culture & Society 25 (1): 108-112.
Schein, Edgar H. 1984. “Coming to a New Awareness of Organizational Culture.” Sloan Management Review 25 (2): 3-16.
Siebold, Guy L. 2007. “The essence of military group cohesion.” Armed Forces & Society33 (2): 286-295.
Smollan, Roy K. and Janet G. Sayers. 2009. “Organizational culture, change and emotions: A qualitative study.” Journal of change management 9 (4): 435-457.
Starr-Glass, David. 2004. “Exploring Organizational Culture: Teaching notes on metaphor, totem and archetypal images.” Journal of Management Education 28 (3): 356-371.
Smith, Laura G. E., Catherine E. Amiot, Joanne R. Smith, Victor J. Callan and Deborah J. Terry. 2013. “The Social Validation and Coping Model of Organizational Identity Development: A Longitudinal Test.” Journal of Management 39 (7): 1952–1978.
Smythe, William E. and Angelina Baydala. 2012. “The hermeneutic background of C. G. Jung.” Journal of Analytical Psychology 57: 57–75.
Szitanyi, Stephanie. 2020. Gender Trouble in the U.S. Military. Cham: Palgrave MacMillan.
Tallman, Bruce. 2003. “The Organization Leader as King, Warrior, Magician and Lover: How Jungian Archetypes Affect the Way Men Lead Organizations.” Organization Development Journal 21 (3): 19-30.
Taylor, Andrea, Felix Santiago and Rilla Hynes. 2019. “Relationships Among Leadership, Organizational Culture, and Support for Innovation”. In Effective and Creative Leadership in Diverse Workforces, edited by Bethany K. Mickahail, and Carlos Tasso Eira de Aquino, 11-42. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
The Economist. 2023. “Canada’s miserly defence spending is increasingly embarrassing”. https://www.economist.com/the-americas/2023/07/24/canadas-miserly-defence-spending-is-increasingly-embarrassing.
The White House. 2021. “Statement by President Joe Biden on the Tenth Anniversary of the Repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell”. https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2021/09/20/statement-by-president-joe-biden-on-the-tenth-anniversary-of-the-repeal-of-dont-ask-dont-tell/.
Thorne, Stephen. 2005. “Rick Hillier”. International Journal 60 (3): 824-830.
Tumilty, Ryan. 2023. “Defence budget facing nearly $1 billion in cuts, Chief of Defence staff says”. National Post. https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/chief-of-defence-staff-military-budget.
Turner, Stephen P. 1977. “Complex organizations as savage tribes.” Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 7: 99-125.
Waddell, Dianne and Amrik S. 1998. Sohal. “Resistance: A constructive tool for change management.” Management Decision 36 (8): 543–548.
Webber, David, Jeff Schimel, Andy Martens, Joseph Hayes and Erik H. Faucher. 2013. “Using a Bug-Killing Paradigm to Understand How Social Validation and Invalidation Affect the Distress of Killing.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 39 (4): 470–481.
Weber, Max. 1919. From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ybema, Sierk and Martha Horvers. 2017. “Resistance Through Compliance: The Strategic and Subversive Potential of Frontstage and Backstage Resistance.” Organization Studies 38 (9): 1233–1251.
Young-Eisendrath, Polly and Terence Dawson eds. 1997. The Cambridge Companion to Jung. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
The published articles are subject to copyright law. All rights are reserved to the “Carol I” National Defense University, regardless of whether all or part of the material are considered, especially the rights to translation, reprinting, re-use of illustrations, quotations, broadcasting through the media, reproduction on microfilms or any other way and storage in data banks. Any replicas without the associated fees are authorized provided the source is acknowledged.
BULLETIN OF "CAROL I" NATIONAL DEFENCE UNIVERSITY 
