Essential approaches to the use of combat drones. Specific elements of the armed conflict in Ukraine

Authors

  • Gheorghe MINCULETE Nicolae Bălcescu” Land Forces Academy, Sibiu, Romania
  • Veronica PĂSTAE “Carol I” National Defence University, Bucharest, Romania

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.53477/2284-9378-23-58

Keywords:

armed conflict, multinational joint and tactical operations, combat drones, swarm drones, jamming and neutralizing drones, drone instructors, drone school.

Abstract

Although used many years ago, by multinational allied forces acting in coalition in Iraq and Afghanistan, combat drones known as “unmanned aircraft systems” (UAS), “unmanned aerial vehicles” (UAV)”, “unmanned combat aerial vehicles” (UCAV) or “remotely piloted vehicles” (RPV) represent a formidable weapon both for NATO states and for the forces fighting in Ukraine. Considering their essential characteristics, dimensions, load capacity, speed, range, flexibility, ease of operation and low costs, these means of combat come with huge advantages in achieving the operational objectives of combatant structures - regardless of the category they belong to. Thus, the present study includes a theoretical approach that can actually be implemented in the military operational realm, because it includes details and essential references to combat drones designed, produced and used by belligerent and non-belligerent states in connection with the armed conflict taking place on Ukrainian territory. Starting from the objective of the study, a series of important directions resulted for strengthening the actual potential of the joint and tactical forces to be used in national and multinational context within the North Atlantic Alliance, against the aggressive force of an adversary state.

References

Adevărul Newspaper. 2023. “The drone war between Russia and Ukraine and their tactical game in the war.” https://adevarul.ro/stiri-externe/europa/razboiul-dronelor-intrerusia-si-ucraina-si-jocul-2272042.html.

Air Force. 2023. “MQ-9 Reaper.” https://www.af.mil/About-Us/Fact-Sheets/Display/Article/104470/mq-9-reaper/.

Andrei, V. 2022. “Drone pilot, a new specialization for Ukrainian military forces. The intention is that each platoon has a UAV operator.” https://ziare.com/ucraina/ucrainarazboi-rusia-invazie-drone-operatori-drone-scoala-pilotaj-1764378.

Bâtcă, M. 2019. “The dreaded MQ-9 Reaper drone, one of the most effective American weapons, at Câmpia Turzii.” Press Trust of the Ministry of National Defense. http://presamil.ro/temuta-drona-mq-9-reaper-una-dintre-cele-mai-eficiente-armeamericane-la-campia-turzii/.

Borcea, T. 2023. “NATO launches an anti-drone strategy for Ukraine and Europe. Joint weapon production plan between Alliance and Kiev. Countering Russian drones in Ukraine and Europe. NATO is working on the first interoperability standard for the members.” https://www.fanatik.ro/nato-face-un-plan-anti-drone-pentru-ucraina-sieuropa-plan-comun-de-productie-de-arme-intre-alianta-si-kiev-20495493.

Borcean, E. 2019. “The US Air Force will invest in combat drones and single-use aircraft.” Tribuna Românească. Romanian newspaper edited and printed in Chicago. https://tribuna.us/emil-borcean-fortele-aeriene-americane-vor-investi-in-drone-de-lupta-siavioane-de-unica-folosinta/.

Botea, R. 2023. “The Ministry of Defense approved the first Romanian jamming system for drones, developed by Blue Space Technology.” Ziarul Financiar. https://www.zf.ro/eveniment/ministerul-apararii-a-aprobat-primul-sistem-romanesc-debruiaj-21842700.

Brodsky, S. 2023. “Russia Says It’s Building Hibernating Drones That Can Sleep for Weeks Before Attacking The Joker takes lengthy naps to hide from electronic countermeasures.” https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/aviation/a44630125/russia-building-hibernating-drones/.

Cârlugea, S. 2023. “Game of Drones. What Russians weapons could have fallen in Dobrogea. Where did they come from and how did they arrive in Romania.” Free Europe Romania. https://romania.europalibera.org/a/ce-drone-au-ajuns-in-romania-sicum/32594519.html.

Costea, C. 2023. “Ukraine allocates one billion dollars for drone production. Purpose: The first fleet of combat maritime drones.” https://m.defenseromania.ro/ucraina-alocaun-miliard-de-dolari-pentru-productia-de-drone-scopul-prima-flota-de-dronemaritime-de-lupta_623796.html.

Dancu, I. 2023. “The Russians transfer air defense to Simferopol and place ‘dragon’s teeth’ in Crimea.” https://www.stiripesurse.ro/rusii-transfera-apararea-antiaeriana-lasimferopol-si-amplaseza-dinti-de-dragon-in-crimeea_3088924.html.

Defense Romania. 2023a. “Ukraine’s army of drones: “Operation Unity” has almost been completed - the first 5,000 PFV drones reach the Ukrainian Armed Forces.” https://m.defenseromania.ro/armata-de-drone-a-ucrainei-un-ong-ucrainean-a-primitprimele-5-000-de-pfv-uri-foto_625001.html.

—. 2023b. “Ukrainian kamikaze drone “Morok” with a range of 800 km: Fundraising for 100 such UAVs was announced.” https://m.defenseromania.ro/drona-kamikazeucraineana-morok-cu-raza-de-actiune-800-km-a-fost-anuntata-strangerea-defonduri-pentru-100-de-astfel-de-uav-uri_624983.html.

—. 2023c. “FPV Drones: The weapon that changed modern warfare can destroy tanks worth several million dollars.” https://m.defenseromania.ro/dronele-fpv-arma-care-aschimbat-razboiul-modern_625069.html.

Dima, F. 2023. “Anti-drone systems: protection against all air threats.” https://idron.ro/blog/sisteme anti drone-protectia-impotriva tuturor amenintarilor aeriene/.

Dumitrache, C. 2023. In the midst of drone war, the Romanian Armed Forces will have a UAV of their own design. The first Bayraktar TB2 drones arrive this year. https://www.defenseromania.ro/in-plin-razboi-al-dronelor-romania-anunta-cand-ajungin-tara-primele-bayraktar-bonus-mapn-lucreaza-la-prima-drona-de-conceptieproprie_624823.html.

Eckstein, M. 2023. “Cardboard drone vendor retools software based on Ukraine war hacks.” https://www.defensenews.com/naval/2023/09/13/cardboard-drone-vendor-retoolssoftware-based-on-ukraine-war-hacks/.

Euronews. 2023a. “MQ-9 Reaper drone: what it is and for what purpose is the $32 million aircraft used.” https://www.euronews.ro/articole/ce-este-si-cum-funtioneaza-odrona-mq-9-reaper.

—. 2023b. “Drones and robots: How the war in Ukraine is driving technological innovation.” https://www.euronews.ro/articole/drone-si-roboti-cum-impulsioneaza-razboiul-dinucraina-inovatia-tehnologica.

European Parliament. 2023. “Unmanned Aircraft Systems integration into European airspace and operation over populated areas.” Policy Department for Structural and Cohesion Policies, Directorate-General for Internal Policies PE 733.124. https://www.europarl.

europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2023/733124/IPOL_STU(2023)733124_EN.pdf.

Free Europe. 2022. “Drone operator training becomes a new specialization for Ukrainian military forces.” https://romania.europalibera.org/a/ukraine-drone-operator-newfront-war-russia/32054549.html.

—. 2023. “Ukrainian UAV manufacturers in the race for “smart drones.” https://romania.europalibera.org/amp/ucraina-drone-razboi-rusia/32615844.html.

G4Media.ro. 2023. “Ukraine has already trained 10,000 drone operators, a Ukrainian minister announces.” https://www.g4media.ro/ucraina-a-instruit-deja-10-000-deoperatori-de-drone-anunta-un-ministru-ucrainean.html.

Giannakis, A., M. Shoesmith, M. Thomas and Weapons and Tactics Team. 2021. “First Artificial Intelligence Swarm Drones recently Utilized on the Battlefield: Implications.” https://www.counterterrorismgroup.com/post/first-artificial-intelligence-swarmdrones-recently-utilized-on-the-battlefield-implications.

Global Security.org. 2023. “MQ-9 Reaper.” https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/aircraft/mq-9.htm.

Goncharenko, R. 2023. “Ukraine: Drone attacks represent «a huge change».” https://amp.dw.com/ro/ucraina-atacurile-cu-drone-reprezint%C4%83-o-schimbareuria%C8%99%C4%83/a-66683132.

Guimartin, J.F. 2023. “Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Military Aerkraft.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/technology/unmanned-aerial-vehicle.

Ilicea, F. 2023. “How Ukrainian civilians are prepared to fly drones: If we don’t fly, the tanks will kill us.” https://adevarul.ro/amp/stiri-externe/europa/cum-sunt-pregatiti-civiliiucraineni-sa-piloteze-2246101.html.

Ionescu, V. 2023. “The $2,000 drone that wages the technological war between Russia and Ukraine.” https://www.go4it.ro/poze/drona-de-2-000-de-dolari-care-poarta-razboiultehnologic-dintre-rusia-si-ucraina-19225772.

Jucan, S. 2023. “The Ukrainian army has lost more than half of the Bradley fighting vehicles received from the US / What we know so far.” https://www.hotnews.ro/stiri-razboi_ucraina-26572025-html.

Knezevic, J. 2023. “Iranian-Supplied “Shahed” Drones are Russia’s Favorite Weapon (For the Time Being).” https://iari.site/2023/06/11/iranian-supplied-shahed-drones-arerussias-favorite-weapon-for-the-time-being/.

Marin, V. 2023. “Three lessons from the war in Ukraine.” https://adevarul.ro/stiri-externe/europa/cele-trei-lectii-ale-razboiului-din-ucraina-2283192.html.

MCDC. 2022. “Multinational Capability Development Campaign. Multi-Domain Multinational Understanding.” https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1128898/MCDC_MDI.pdf.

Mihalache, V. 2023. “Ukraine uses drones equipped with amazingly efficient artificial intelligence.” https://www.aktual24.ro/ucraina-a-introdus-in-serviciu-drone-echipatecu-inteligenta-artificiala-cu-eficienta-uimitoare/.

Minculete, G. 2023. Relational determinations regarding the modernization of operational logistics. Sibiu: Techno Media Publishing House.

Montalti, E. 2023. “Counter Drones Capabilities Innovation in US Armed Forces.” Info Flash Finabel European Army Interoperability Centre. https://finabel.org/counter-dronescapabilities-innovation-in-us-armed-forces/.

NATO. 2022. “NATO Communications and Information Agency (NCI Agency).” https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics_69332.htm.

Navy Recognition. 2023. “IDEF 2023: Ukraine firm STE unveils maritime drone USV Magura V5.” https://navyrecognition.com/index.php/naval-news/naval-news-archive/2023/july/13391-idef-2023-ukraine-firm-ste-unveils-maritime-drone-usv-magura-v5.html.

Orjanu, G. 2023. “The Ukrainian “army of drones” destroyed 220 Russian pieces of equipment in one week - a spectacular move compared to three months ago.” https://www.defenseromania.ro/armata-de-drone-ucraineana-a-distrus-220-de-echipamente-rusestiintr-o-saptamana-salt-spectaculos-fata-de-acum-trei-luni_624842.html.

Pricop, S. 2023. “What we know about the MQ-9 Reaper, the American drone that was hit by a Russian plane over the Black Sea.” https://www.libertatea.ro/stiri/mq-9-reaper-ce-estedrona-americana-care-a-fost-lovita-de-un-avion-rusesc-deasupra-marii-negre-si-cumeste-folosita-4480262.

Răducanu, C. 2023. “Another problem for Ukraine. Russian engineers have developed “invisible drones”.” https://www.infofinanciar.ro/inca-o-problema-pentru-ucraina-inginerii-rusi-audezvoltat-drone-invizibile.html.

RFI România. 2022. “One year since the chaotic US withdrawal from Afghanistan. “Not only Biden administration is to blame.” https://www.rfi.ro/politica-148410-retragere-haoticasua-afganistan-administratia-biden.

Soare, C. 2023. “What role FPV drones play on the Ukrainian front: Their success rate is between 50%-80%, and the Russians try to keep up with the Ukrainians in the number of attacks.” https://www.defenseromania.ro/ce-rol-joaca-drone-de-tip-fpv-pe-frontul-dinucraina_624879.html.

Stoica, D. 2023. “The Pentagon is building its fleet of AI drones. What is Replicator, the secret weapon that “changes the game” of power.” https://adevarul.ro/stiri-externe/sua/pentagonul-isi-face-flota-de-drone-ai-ce-este-2298459.html.

Svitlyk, Y. 2023. “All about General Atomics MQ-9 Reaper drones.” https://root-nation.com/ro/ua/articles-ua/weapons-ua/ua-general-atomics-mq-9-reaper/.

The Times of Israel. 2023. “In first, Israel reportedly grants licenses to export anti drone systems to Ukraine.” https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/in-first-israel-reportedlygrants-licenses-to-export-anti-drone-systems-to-ukraine/.

Top War. 2023. “In Russia, a line of universal FPV drones “Joker” has been developed for use in the NWO zone.” https://en.topwar.ru/217596-v-rossii-razrabotana-linejka-universalnyhfpv-dronov-dzhoker-dlja-primenenija-v-zone-svo.html.

Tudor, G. 2023. “High school pupils in Russia will have a new subject matter: the use of drones in combat.” https://www.aktual24.ro/elevii-de-liceu-din-rusia-vor-avea-o-noua-materiescolara-folosirea-in-lupta-a-dronelor/.

Vornik, O. 2023. “Why a hard-kill strategy doesn’t work against combat drones.” https://www.aspistrategist.org.au/why-a-hard-kill-strategy-doesnt-work-against-combat-drones/.

Wright-Patterson AFB. 2019. “XQ-58A Valkyrie demonstrator completes inaugural flight.” https://www.wpafb.af.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/1777743/xq-58a-valkyriedemonstrator-completes-inaugural-flight/.

Ziua News. 2023. “The USA are building a “forward observation base” in Romania and investing tens of millions of dollars. Drones to the Black Sea.” https://m.ziuanews.ro/stiri/sua-faco-baz-militar-naintat-n-rom-nia-i-investesc-zeci-de-milioane-de-dolari-drone-c-tremarea-neagr-1578914.

Downloads

Published

2024-01-18

How to Cite

MINCULETE, G., & PĂSTAE, V. . (2024). Essential approaches to the use of combat drones. Specific elements of the armed conflict in Ukraine. BULLETIN OF "CAROL I" NATIONAL DEFENCE UNIVERSITY, 12(4), 208–224. https://doi.org/10.53477/2284-9378-23-58

Issue

Section

Articles