President Vladimir Putin’s speech at the Victoria Day parade in the light of some Ciceronian rhetorical principles
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53477/2284-9378-23-54Keywords:
principles of classical rhetoric, M. T. Cicero, logical, affective, ethical arguments, persuasive strategies, discursive strategies.Abstract
The purpose of this article is to examine the manner in which three of the principles of Ciceronian rhetoric and oratory are used in the speech of President V. Putin on the occasion of the Victory Day parade. The first of them, regarding the auditor’s information, is partially respected by the Russian president, in that he presents too little data intended to provide a somewhat concrete picture of how Western countries have reported, over time, to Russia’s defense requirements. Next, we bring enough examples to demonstrate the orator’s preference for the principle that consists in convincing the audience by appealing to arguments of an affective nature. The third, convincing the public through ethical arguments, strictly depends on the achievement of the previous ones. The degree of respect for each one emerges from the specific quotes in the content. The natural conclusion of the approach is that the Russian president prefers only one of them, failing, in our opinion, to effectively capitalize on the other two, a fact that has (or should have) repercussions on the persuasion of the audience.
References
Aristotel. 2004. Retorica, ediție bilingvă. Bucharest: IRI Publishing House.
Borchin, Mirela. 2007. Comunicare și argumentare, teorie și aplicații. Timișoara: Excelsior Art.
Cazacu, Aurel M. 2007. Teoria argumentării. Bucharest: Romania Press.
Cicero. 1973. Opere alese, vol. II. Bucharest: Univers Publishing House.
Cizek, Eugen. 1994. Istoria literaturii latine. Bucharest: Adevărul SA Society.
EuroNews. 2023. „Vladimir Putin, discurs la un an de la invazia rusă: „Ei au pornit războiul, iar noi am folosit forța pentru a-l opri”.” https://www.euronews.ro/articole/putin-faceevaluarea-unui-an-de-razboi-presedintele-rusiei-isi-va-prezenta-viziun.
Frumușani, Daniela-Rovența. 1994. Introducere în teoria argumentării. Bucharest: University of Bucharest Publishing House.
Gava, Ioan-Radu. 2023. Vladimir Putin, discurs integral. https://www.dcnews.ro/vladimirputin-discurs-integral_906329.html.
Jucan, Sebastian. 2023. „VIDEO. Vladimir Putin, discurs agresiv la un an de la invazia în Ucraina.” https://www.hotnews.ro/stiri-razboi_ucraina-26096882-live-vladimir-putinisi-tine-marti-discursul-anual-fata-parlamentului-rus.htm.
Leordean, Alexandru. 1992. Curs de logică. Bucharest: Military Publishing House.
Nedea, Raluca-Mihaela. 2007. Discursurile lui Cicero. Bucharest: Romanian Academy, National Fundation for Science and Art, Iorgu Iordan – Al. Rosetti Institute of Linguistics.
Pop, Radu. 2023. „Discursul integral al președintelui Vladimir Putin în fața Adunării Federale a Federației Ruse.” https://www.stiripesurse.ro/discursul-integral-al-presedinteluivladimir-putin-in-fata-adunarii-federale-a-federatiei-ruse_2802920.html.
Stoianovici, Drăgan. 2005. Argumentare și gândire critică. București: Editura Universității din București.
Stroe, Constantin. 2007. Retorica și teoria argumentării. Pitești: Pământul Publishing House.
Ziaristii.com. 2023. „VIDEO. Discursul bolnav al lui Putin, după un an de atrocități.” https://ziaristii.com/video-discursul-bolnav-al-lui-putin-dupa-un-de-atrocitati-occidentulinceput-razboiul-noi-facut-tot-posibilul-sa-l-oprim-poporul-ucrainean-este-ostaticul-vestului-si-al-regimului-nazi/.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
The published articles are subject to copyright law. All rights are reserved to the “Carol I” National Defense University, regardless of whether all or part of the material are considered, especially the rights to translation, reprinting, re-use of illustrations, quotations, broadcasting through the media, reproduction on microfilms or any other way and storage in data banks. Any replicas without the associated fees are authorized provided the source is acknowledged.